Kentucky Derby Facing Controversy
Everybody watches the game on TV. Even in the arena, on giant screens. Or at the scorer’s table, where basketball officials gather to decide whether 1.1 seconds should be restored to the clock. Or on the football field, where the referee gets a video to peek at contested calls.
Horse racing has used replays for decades but seemed immune to major controversies on the track until Saturday’s Kentucky Derby. In the 145th Run for the Roses, Maximum Security crossed the finish line first, but an objection was filed. Stewards viewed the video and, after 22 minutes, upheld the objection, took down the winner and started a controversy that could end up in court.
Maximum Security clearly drifted across the sloppy track and impeded Will to Win. The owners of Maximum Security appealed to the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission on Monday and the appeal was rejected. So Maximum Security finished 17th after “winning” the race and then being disqualified.
Most of the folks involved with racing seemed to back the decision by the stewards. And blaming instant replay for this correction of an infraction committed on the track – a first in Derby history – is a mistake.
Yes, too often these fraction-of-a-second reversals of plays in football seem to make no sense. The game isn’t played in super slow motion – in fact, it’s way faster than it seems on television. And it gets tiresome to see basketball officials having to consult a TV over whether a shot was a 3-pointer or for how much time should be on the clock.
It’s also important to get calls right, which is why replay is part of every sport.
Maximum Security finished first but did so by veering across the track and cutting off competitors. That creates dangers and violates the rules.
So we’ve seen something we hadn’t seen before. And though Maximum Security’s owners are upset, the horse has had no comment.
Post By: Larry Weisman, a longtime sportswriter for USA TODAY, blogs for Twistity.com. Follow him on Twitter @MrLarryWeisman
-
Correa joined the Mets with a $315 million contract. Recently, baseball player Carlos Correa announced that he had cut...
-
Oklahoma and Texas will depart from the college sports conference at the end of the season. The Big 12...
-
Robert Kraft wants to re-sign Brady just long enough that he can retire as a Patriot. Earlier this week,...
-
The skilled third-baseman will be enshrined in Cooperstown. Scott Rolen is one of the most skilled and recognized third-basemen...
-
Brady’s 23rd football season has ended. On Monday, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Dallas Cowboys went head-to-head for...
-
Smith has been fired after one season with the team. Over the weekend, the owners of the Houston Texans...
-
Pelé passed due to complications related to colon cancer. On Thursday night, the sporting world received unfortunate news: Pelé,...
-
His return heralded a victory over the Phoenix Suns. On Sunday, Houston Rockets coach Stephen Silas needed to take...
-
Mayfield will be available on waiver to other NFL teams. After an underwhelming performance in his current role as...
-
Mike White led the team to a decisive victory over the Bears over the weekend. On Saturday, the New...
-
The game has been moved out of New York due to an encroaching snowstorm. This weekend, the Buffalo Bills...
-
Negative pushback prompted the team to give the role to someone else. Recently, the Brooklyn Nets have been in...