Kentucky Derby Facing Controversy
Everybody watches the game on TV. Even in the arena, on giant screens. Or at the scorer’s table, where basketball officials gather to decide whether 1.1 seconds should be restored to the clock. Or on the football field, where the referee gets a video to peek at contested calls.
Horse racing has used replays for decades but seemed immune to major controversies on the track until Saturday’s Kentucky Derby. In the 145th Run for the Roses, Maximum Security crossed the finish line first, but an objection was filed. Stewards viewed the video and, after 22 minutes, upheld the objection, took down the winner and started a controversy that could end up in court.
Maximum Security clearly drifted across the sloppy track and impeded Will to Win. The owners of Maximum Security appealed to the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission on Monday and the appeal was rejected. So Maximum Security finished 17th after “winning” the race and then being disqualified.
Most of the folks involved with racing seemed to back the decision by the stewards. And blaming instant replay for this correction of an infraction committed on the track – a first in Derby history – is a mistake.
Yes, too often these fraction-of-a-second reversals of plays in football seem to make no sense. The game isn’t played in super slow motion – in fact, it’s way faster than it seems on television. And it gets tiresome to see basketball officials having to consult a TV over whether a shot was a 3-pointer or for how much time should be on the clock.
It’s also important to get calls right, which is why replay is part of every sport.
Maximum Security finished first but did so by veering across the track and cutting off competitors. That creates dangers and violates the rules.
So we’ve seen something we hadn’t seen before. And though Maximum Security’s owners are upset, the horse has had no comment.
Post By: Larry Weisman, a longtime sportswriter for USA TODAY, blogs for Twistity.com. Follow him on Twitter @MrLarryWeisman
-
The Bears got Claypool in exchange for a 2023 second-round pick. This week, the Pittsburgh Steelers cut a deal...
-
Belichick has cycled through several players in search of the right one. Recently, the New England Patriots have been...
-
The field needs new posts after overzealous fans dumped the old ones in the river. Over the weekend, the...
-
Hutchinson grew up idolizing the Patriots and Tom Brady. This Sunday, the Detroit Lions are scheduled to take on...
-
Judge has broken Babe Ruth’s record and tied with Roger Maris. Last week, New York Yankees center fielder and...
-
Judge is one homer away from beating the Bambino’s record. Babe Ruth, AKA The Great Bambino, AKA The Sultan...
-
Trout is one homer off from an MLB record. Last night, the Los Angeles Angels played the Cleveland Guardians....
-
Jones spoke about the new offense at their training camp. The New England Patriots are currently in the midst...
-
A fight broke out on the last day of joint practice. Thursday was the last day of joint practice...
-
Donaldson clinched the game for his team in extra innings. Wednesday night saw a major nail-biter game between the...
-
The Yankees have landed two impressive players from the Oakland Athletics. The New York Yankees, superstars of the American...
-
NFL+ offers game coverage for $4.99 a month. Following suit with other companies and brands establishing their own streaming...